Unfortunately, the introduction was cut short when class ended. I think I need to point out a few more things about online journals, which are a pretty unique format. There is, indeed, much to discuss. Here are some points:
- For our purposes, online journals should be defined as outlets that periodically publish content of a literary nature digitally—on websites, in eBooks, through emails and PDFs, for example. The most common online journals are websites.
- Success for an online journal is similar to what stands for success as a poet. Most poets aren't after big bucks, and neither are most editors. The impulse, most of the time, is to share literature that they love. Online journals succeed when the people who run them are passionate about it.
- Online journals are often run by people with little training in web development, editing, business development or anything that would really qualify them for, well, anything. The thing that qualifies a person to start a journal is the same thing that qualifies anyone to be a writer: an interest in doing it. There are hundreds (at least) of online journals could be considered successful only because they've stuck with it. Start an online journal, make a bunch of issues, and people will hear about it and submit work and share the work and there will be readers.
- Online journals are distinct from print journals for lots of reasons.
- They aren't restricted by the cost of printing,
- therefore they can publish on a different schedule (print journals often run 2 - 4 issues a year, because of the expense),
- and they can publish things that print journals can't, such as
- things with color;
- things that move;
- things that don't have to sell really well;
- therefore online journals are driving a lot of experimentation in literature, such as
- microfiction (it's been said that stories published online should be fewer than 1000 words, because that is the Internet attention span; one could argue that this resulted in lots of sites like Smokelong and Dogzplot);
- video poetry (see Steve Roggenbuck);
- interesting techniques for presenting translations (see Action Yes);
- flarf (written about, inscrutably [as is appropriate] in Wired);
- "amateur" poetry (see Everyday Genius);
- ways to navigate through the content (can't think of a good example, but Sidebrow made a print journal that was pretty hypertextual and I'm surprised I haven't seen online journals do this more);
- user-generated content (eg comment boxes) (also I can't think of an example);
- multimedia collaborations (what was that journal that had a story by an author combined with a song from a band combined with an image from an artist?);
- interactivity across media (like, starting a story on a website and augmenting it with Twitter, another website, eBooks, PDFs, and so on).
- Work that is published in an online journal has the potential to be read an unlimited number of times for eternity. As long as there are servers to host it, the work can be available. Print journals go away.
- Relatedly, online journals have radically different considerations from print journals. They are challenged to develop a new meanings for what it means to publish. It will benefit you to read this manifesto on "subcompact publishing" written at Craigmod, which says:
... why do so many of our digital magazines publish on the same schedule, with the same number of articles as their print counterparts? Using the same covers? Of course, they do because it’s easier to maintain identical schedules across mediums. To not design twice. To not test twice (or, at all).
Unfortunately — from a medium-specific user experience point of view — it’s almost impossible to produce a digitally indigenous magazine beholden to those legacy constraints. Why? Not least because we use tablets and smartphones very differently than we use printed publications.
One of the great benefits of being part of the emergent publishing world is that you don’t have multiple mediums to publish across. You can and probably should focus squarely on digital. Perhaps later — contingent on market demand and content quality — you can consider publishing a print anthology to give your publication a stronger literal edge.
So what are these so called ‘indigenous’ qualities of digital? ... - Print journals, like everything—book publishers, Coca-Cola, churches, the government, sandwich meat—have websites. How is the website of a print journal different from an online journal? This is a big question, and the answers differ. Often, a print journal will even post original content on their website, and will do this very well, very cohesively—on a consistent schedule, with a dedicated editor and work of a unified tone, for example. Does that make them an online journal? My thinking is twofold:
- What is their main focus? Are they posting work online to promote the print journal? This is usually easy to determine (often a journal will post a piece or two from the print issue online, or teaser excerpts from the print issue). If the website is basically a promotion engine, I would say—get off my lawn—it's not an online journal.
- Have they developed a unique concept specific to a digital presentation? Because this is certainly a characteristic of (at least the good) online journals: they have given long consideration to how the digital format should influence the content. There's no reason a journal can't rethink both print and digital. Several do, including Hobart, whose Web Features are all the things I described above: scheduled, with dedicated editors, unified/thematic content, as well as focused on how they present that content.
- A reverse example (or a counter example, perhaps): recently I was asked to guest edit Sententia, a print journal, and the publisher gave me license to develop a new concept for the issue, the journal's fifth. I knew I wanted to have a digital component for it, and decided it would be simply to make the journal available first as an eBook. That guided my editorial considerations. How? Because of the digital component, I chose not to include any poetry. Why? Because poetry is—in my view and abilities—still pretty limited by the technology of eBooks. What I'm saying is, the different formats must be guided by the format conceptually to be true to what it is essentially.
- Bonus fold: I am in no way arguing or even trying to suggest that print is dead or print publishers are out of date. Even mainstream print publishers publish things very well online, and in many cases I would argue that what they create is an online journal.
- Online journals rarely pay writers as much as print journals, but many are as well regarded by writers in-the-know.
- In many ways, it's still the like the wild west for online journals. They come and go often. They steal from each other. No one is yet sure of the impact they're making. But the people who are involved with them seem to have a good time and derive value from the ability to share work and interact with their audience as they all figure things out together.
- Exceptions and omissions abound. I welcome corrections and additions in the comments.
Points 3.5, 3.6, 3.7, 3.8 and 6.3 above don't have examples listed. If you can find some and post them in the comments, I'll ... give you ... extra credit. (Look at Electric Literature in relation to 3.8 and HarperPerennial's 52 Stories regarding 6.3.)
No comments:
Post a Comment